Thursday, February 1, 2007   ·  
#635: YOUR FICTION, MY PAIN

Did you know that bloggers, people like me and possibly you, are "...living in a world where emotions may be real but everything else is make-believe..."? I know. It's shocking. I had no idea, but this article from cbc.ca discussing Michael Keren's new book, "Blogosphere: The New Political Arena", opened my eyes. I thought that I was entertaining people and even reaching out at times, finding connections with others that I might not have otherwise found, but I know now that I was blind.

Keren "...suggests that blogs often have the opposite effect by creating feelings of loneliness for those who aren't lucky enough to reach 'celebrity' status." I mean, wow, what an insight. I knew that I felt sad sometimes, even a little lonely if it happened to be a Friday night and my cats were ignoring me, but I really didn't know that the internet was to blame. It has been my lack of celebrity that has been fanning the flames of my discontent. It wasn't necessarily just my real friends that I was missing; it was a decent hit count on StatCounter.

Knowing this has made me very empathetic to all those athletes who never make it to the Olympics, all those off-broadway actors who will never make it to the main stage, the musicians who never earn a gold record. The sheer number of individuals who are never able to reach the top of their field is staggering. Until today, the depth of the world's sorrows was unknown to me. How do I stumble forward, armed with the cold fact that the world we inhabit breeds so much defeat?

Now that I am aware that I am "...isolated and lonely, living in a virtual reality instead of forming real relationships", I can do something about it. Honestly, after reading about Michael Keren's book and his enlightening quotes in the cbc.ca article, I don't know how I was able to see my readers as real people with whom I could have real relationships. I mean, look at you. Where are you? You are not here. You are just little bits and bytes of type with names you chose for yourselves. Who chooses their own names, I ask you? Hippies and con artists, I say! I can't believe the company I've been pretending to keep, you bunch of smelly liars.

Who could doubt the veracity of Keren's well-researched thoughts on blogging? He followed the blogs of nine individuals in his book. NINE. I don't know how he managed to keep up. When he talks about a female Canadian blogger who is living out in the woods that remains lonely after the death of her cat even though she blogs, I totally know where he's coming from, because it is obvious that it is blogging and not her woodsy isolation or pet death that is causing her loneliness. She blogged, and people who weren't real responded when her cat died, and their lack of realness caused her more pain.

It is you readers of and commenters on these weblogs that are truly to blame for this horrible rash of Blogger Depressive Disorder (BDD). You are not real, and each time you comment or write a blogger an e-mail, you are only underlining your lack of actuality. You are saying Look! It's like I'm here but I'm not! Your attempts at communications are diminished to mere taunts. You are further depressing possibly hundreds if not thousands of innocent yet lonely and deluded bloggers who do not know that by communicating via the internet they are traversing a virtual territory populated by people whose lack of realness renders their communication hollow.

I am devastated. Even in the midst of my realization that you do not exist, I still write, so desperate am I to diffuse this immense loneliness which you, to a greater extent, are responsible for. YOU. So much power you have, even though you lack realness. Even from the virtual plane, you can reach into my chest and crush my spirit with your fictions, and let me tell you, the ensuing BDD is a terrible state indeed.

At least, according to Keren, my emotions are real, even if everything else is make-believe. If nothing else, I can believe in my inconsolable loneliness. You may not be real, my celebrity may be as a whisper in raging storm, but the effects of this nihilistic depth charge to the core of my being is the real truth borne of my fruitless foray into the virtual world of blogging.

Let Keren's words be a warning to you who also blog: "'Some of us are going to be embraced by the mainstream media, but the majority of us remain in the dark, remain in the loneliness.'"
   ·   permanent link   ·   share/bookmark    ·   subscribe
Hello. I am underemployed. Consider this my tip jar. ♥
Check out the fine folks who completed my goal to get to BlogHer '09.




26 comments:
Anonymous Elsie

I like being a virtual friend. I try not to lie, although I am prone to exaggeration for effect. And I'm only smelly two, sometimes three days a week.  
Blogger sweetney

bwahahahaahaaaa! oh, that was RICH.  
Anonymous Elsie

Edit: I meant say that I am smelly only two or three days a week. I am many things on most days.  
Blogger Miscellaneous-Mum

What a ray of sunshine Keren is.  
Blogger palinode

If the article is an accurate reflection of Keren's views, then he misunderstands the nature and purpose of weblogs. I'm guessing that lots of bloggers would be flattered if the mainstream media came knocking, but I doubt that the majority are reaping only bitterness for their efforts. And anyway, when it comes to online friends, I'd prefer a look at why and how those friendships work, not a facile dismissal.  
Blogger Sue

I like the quote in response to his criticism by one Arian Hopkins, obviously not a professor,

"That's harsh."

I have no desire to read Keren's book dissing bloggers when it is really obvious he started his own blog, got no comments, and became existentially lonely as he smoked dope and listened to Eleanor Rigby.

And there is a dramatic difference between political blogging and personal blogging and a dramatic difference between types of blogs in the subcategories under those headings, not to mention lots of blending of mediums. I mean, most of us personal bloggers have no desire to change the world. We just feel good about changing our underwear, right Schmutzie?

And another thing!

I forgot the other thing. I got stuck on underwear.  
Anonymous Neil

I don't think he was referring to you, because aren't you a celebrity? If I remember correctly, aren't you the second or third best blog in Canada from that vote last month? You will never be lonely like the rest of us.

But maybe Kren is right. Maybe I should go back to the more productive and social activity I used to do before blogging -- watching TV.  
Blogger schmutzie

Neil, if I'm at all famous, I'm Canadian famous, which means that people would think they kind of recognized me from somewhere but couldn't decide if it was from that "Danger Bay" episode back in 1989.  
Blogger May-B

Dude, you were on Danger Bay? Now that is awesome. For serious.

I think that guy has no actual clue what he's talking about. Who only looks at 7 or 9 people to make generalizations about the whole blogging world? That makes no sense.

Although, I do like being here and yet not being here. It's very surreal.  
Blogger cenobyte

YOU WERE IN DANGER BAY!!!???

Man. You're, like, FAMOUS!

I was going to call you to go and have some real, interpersonal relationship, but then I decided to stay home and read blogs instead. So now we'd have nothing to talk about if we did interpersonally relate, and I just couldn't do that to either of us.

Maybe when the server's down again?  
Blogger schmutzie

I WAS NOT IN "DANGER BAY".

I only used that as an example of how people recognize the famous in Canada.

If I had been in "Danger Bay", though, I would be so fucking cool.  
Blogger j.k.a

that article was so enlightening.

but I comment, therefore I am not.

I guess there is nothing left for me know but to post myself further and further into isolation and delusion.

alas, my poor blogging soul.  
Anonymous pagalina

So is this danger bay also canadian? I youtubed* it to find this opening http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q-m5J10e2Rg I can't believe you were in it! ;)

(*am i the first to verbize the word youtube? wheee me!)  
Blogger schmutzie

Yes, that's the "Danger Bay" I was never on. It's a Canadian classic.  
Blogger Jessica

That explains my occasional loneliness and feelings of isolation. And here I though it was because I am a new mother and have recently moved to a foreign country where I don't yet speak the language. Thanks for the enlightening words of Keran, now I can just quit blogging and it will solve my problems. Ahh... [sigh of relief]  
Anonymous Jo

My name is Jo. It really is. And I am here. No really, I'm here. Do you feel less depressed now?  
Anonymous savia

Are you sure you weren't on Beachcombers? I swear I recognize you from somewhere.

Maybe it was Switchback?  
Blogger Marisa

Ow. I was drinking coffee and... some of my virtual coffee came out my virtual nose, I guess. So perhaps my pain is also virtual. And yet I feel it - a philosophical question for the ages.

For those of us reading via RSS, could you move the Bitacle blurb down by a line somehow? It runs into your text...  
Blogger schmutzie

That's interesting, Marisa, because I didn't purposely put a bitacle blurb in my RSS. I'm not sure what that's about.  
Blogger May-B

I wish I had been on Danger Bay. I always thought Jonah was hot. Of course, when I catch it on TV now, I think the Dad is better.  
Blogger sumo

You can try to deny your fame all you want. We all know the truth. Last year you medaled for blogging (2nd for Best Canadian Blog in the Weblog Awards and 3rd for Best Blog in the Canadian Blog Awards), so that makes you a celebrity. You're like the Nancy Kerrigan of blogging!

Of course... Nancy isn't Canadian. And comparing a Canadians-only award to the Olympics is not exactly fair. Let's see if I can find a more accurate analogy. If you look at the last couple Canadian Figure Skating Championships, 2nd and 3rd went to Mira Leung and Lesley Hawker. You are like Mira Leung or Lesley Hawker.

OK, you win. I retract my previous statement; you're not a celebrity.

But you'll always be Nancy Kerrigan to me!  
Blogger cenobyte

Oh, don't try to be coy *now*. Maybe you were in Danger Bay but you didn't know it; like it wasn't a conscious decision do be on Danger Bay, but one day they were filming in a bank and you went into that bank and didn't see them because you had on your dark glasses and they caught you on film and so actually you *were* on Danger Bay but you're not legally obligated to admit it because you didn't sign a contract or a release and now you're being asked to please deny ever having been involved with that Danger Bay episode in that fateful bank on that special day. I bet that's it.

Or maybe you thought that you were there for the episode of Degrassi Jr. High you were on, but at the last minute, they changed their minds and decided to film Danger Bay, but they didn't tell you so you always looked for yourself in Degrassi, but you were actally in the Bay. That's plausible, too.  
Anonymous ozma

I don't know about the rest of you people but I can't FIND any friends in real life. Also, the real people? They call you on the phone and stuff. And then you have answer said phone. Etc. This sort of thing works out much better, all told.  
Anonymous Adam Durrant

As if the exercise of writing through proper academic channels is any less existentially lonely than composing an article for an online publication. I’ll take the online audience providing their genuine insight on a topic over peer and professional review committees any day. Keren is just an old man who is threatened by the opportunities for egalitarian dissemination of information that is presented by the internet and blogging.

Also, I think we can see his position as a response, by a certain element of the academic community, to encroachment of the everyman on the monopoly of thought previously held within the walls of academia. No longer do you need to have significant letters following your name in order to allow your voice to be heard. Thought, one of the last great aristocratic institutions of the Western world, is in the throws of being democratized.

However, there is a lot of drek on the angst of teenagers online which retards the process for the rest of us.

Best,

AD  
Blogger Tina T-P

How timely - I'm doing a service at our Unitarian church next month on the "Community of blogging" Do you mind if I quote some from your post today? Leave me a comment on my blog if it's OK. THX T.  
Blogger Tina T-P

It's ironic, isn't it, that academia (those stuffed shirts who spend all their time studying all of the rest of us) thinks that bloggers are a sad and lonely bunch. Many of the "very real" people that I have met through my blog have become good friends, and I see so many groups as very tight networks of caring people. Heck look at the cat bloggers - they are always helping pay someone's vet bills or sending surprise boxes of toys and kibble & although I refuse to call canned cat food "stinky goodness" I really enjoy reading their blogs. Keep up the good work on your blog - maybe someday we'll all be famous. :-) T.  

post a comment · Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom] · main page



« monthly archives